From 964897bdc01bd4c55e67af97daeaefda80a8a37e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: =?UTF-8?q?Rados=C5=82aw=20Gierwia=C5=82o?= Date: Sun, 30 Nov 2025 20:22:07 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] docs: move completed tasks to archive and update TODO status - Add recent completions to COMPLETED.md: - 3-Tier Account System & Fairness Algorithm (2025-11-29) - Mobile-first Design Improvements (2025-11-29) - Test Bot for Automated Testing (2025-11-29) - Ratings & Stats System (2025-11-30, 9 E2E tests) - Matching Runs Audit & origin_run_id Tracking (2025-11-30, 30 tests) - Documentation Reorganization (2025-11-30) - Update TODO.md current status (342/342 tests passing - 100%) - Remove "Recently Completed" sections from TODO.md - Update implemented scenarios list --- docs/TODO.md | 60 +++------ docs/archive/COMPLETED.md | 247 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 2 files changed, 259 insertions(+), 48 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/TODO.md b/docs/TODO.md index 3b4ae23..c9213af 100644 --- a/docs/TODO.md +++ b/docs/TODO.md @@ -6,41 +6,11 @@ ## Current Status -**Phase:** MVP Complete - Ready for Production Deployment -**Tests:** 285/286 passing - 99.7% (73% coverage) -**Status:** Awaiting infrastructure setup +**Phase:** MVP Complete - Production Ready +**Tests:** 342/342 passing - 100% ✅ (72.5% coverage) +**Recent Work:** Matching runs audit, ratings & stats system, comprehensive test suite completed (2025-11-30) -### High Priority Tasks - -**🟡 HIGH: Matching Algorithm Integration Tests** -- **Issue:** Only unit tests for helper functions exist, no end-to-end tests for `runMatching()` -- **Test Plan:** `backend/src/__tests__/matching-scenarios.md` (18 scenarios defined) -- **Priority Phases:** - 1. **Phase 1:** Fundamentals (TC1-3) - Basic happy path, NOT_FOUND scenarios - 2. **Phase 2:** Collision Detection (TC4-9) - Buffers, slot mapping - 3. **Phase 3:** Limits & Workload (TC10-11) - **CRITICAL bug verification** (recording-recording collision) - 4. **Phase 4:** Fairness & Tiers (TC12-16) - Tier penalties, sorting priority - 5. **Phase 5:** Edge Cases (TC17-18) - Sanity checks -- **Impact:** Ensures matching algorithm works correctly end-to-end, verifies critical bug fixes -- **Status:** Test plan documented, implementation pending -- **Extended Scenarios:** See comprehensive test scenarios below - -### Recently Completed (2025-11-30) -- **Ratings & Stats System** - Auto matches update recordingsDone/recordingsReceived stats, manual matches don't - - E2E test: `backend/src/__tests__/ratings-stats-flow.test.js` (9 test scenarios) - - Atomic stats application with `statsApplied` flag to prevent double-counting - - Frontend UI already exists in `RatePartnerPage.jsx` - -### Previously Completed (2025-11-29) -- 3-Tier Account System (BASIC/SUPPORTER/COMFORT) with fairness algorithm -- Dual Buffer System (prep before + rest after dancing) -- Clickable Usernames with @ prefix in profiles -- Country Flags in Event Chat -- Mobile-first Design Improvements (page titles on mobile) -- Recording Matching System Improvements (collision detection, schedule config) -- Test Bot for Automated Testing - -**Full history:** See `docs/archive/COMPLETED.md` +**Full implementation history:** See `docs/archive/COMPLETED.md` --- @@ -51,12 +21,14 @@ ### Implementation Status -#### ✅ Implemented Scenarios -- **S1-S3:** Basic flow, collision detection, limits (covered by existing tests) -- **S7.1-7.2:** Manual match blocks auto suggestions (implemented 2025-11-30) -- **S10:** Ratings & Stats System (implemented 2025-11-30, E2E tested) -- **S12:** Multi-heat collision detection (existing logic) -- **S14.1:** Only recorder can accept/reject (implemented in MVP) +#### ✅ Implemented Scenarios (See docs/archive/COMPLETED.md for details) +- **S1-S3:** Basic flow, collision detection, limits - 19 integration tests +- **S7.1-7.2:** Manual match blocks auto suggestions - Implemented & tested +- **S10:** Ratings & Stats System - 9 E2E tests (atomic updates, race prevention) +- **S11.3-11.4:** Matching Run Details API - Admin endpoints with filtering +- **S12:** Multi-heat collision detection - Covered in matching algorithm tests +- **S14.1:** Only recorder can accept/reject - Implemented in MVP +- **Matching Runs Audit:** 6 comprehensive tests (origin_run_id tracking) #### 🔴 Critical Gaps (P0 - Before Production) @@ -83,14 +55,10 @@ #### 📋 Medium Priority (P2 - Q1 2025) -6. **S11.3-11.4: Matching Run Details API** - - Endpoint: `GET /matching-runs/:id/suggestions` - - Filters: `onlyAssigned`, `includeNotFound` - -7. **S15.3: Zombie Matches Cleanup** +6. **S15.3: Zombie Matches Cleanup** - Auto-cancel pending matches older than 30 days -8. **S16.3: Email Reminders** +7. **S16.3: Email Reminders** - Reminder before event for accepted recording assignments ### Test Scenarios by Category diff --git a/docs/archive/COMPLETED.md b/docs/archive/COMPLETED.md index ff81fd1..40000db 100644 --- a/docs/archive/COMPLETED.md +++ b/docs/archive/COMPLETED.md @@ -938,8 +938,251 @@ Major refactoring of frontend code to extract reusable components and add status --- -**Last Updated:** 2025-11-23 (Recording Matching + Frontend Refactoring completed) +## ✅ 3-Tier Account System & Fairness Algorithm (COMPLETED 2025-11-29) + +**Status:** Completed +**Time Spent:** ~6 hours +**Commits:** Multiple commits + +### Overview +Implemented a 3-tier account system (BASIC, SUPPORTER, COMFORT) with fairness algorithm for recording assignment. The system tracks how many times users have recorded others vs been recorded, creating a "karma" system that ensures fair distribution of recording duties. + +### Backend Implementation +- [x] ✅ **AccountTier enum** - BASIC, SUPPORTER, COMFORT +- [x] ✅ **User model updates** + - `accountTier` field (default: BASIC) + - `recordingsDone` counter + - `recordingsReceived` counter +- [x] ✅ **EventParticipant model** + - `accountTierOverride` field for event-specific tier upgrades (e.g., Comfort Pass) +- [x] ✅ **Fairness algorithm** in matching service + - Debt calculation: `recordingsDone - recordingsReceived` + - SUPPORTER tier: -10 fairness penalty (records less often) + - COMFORT tier: -50 fairness penalty (rarely records) + - Sorting priority: Location > Fairness > Load balancing +- [x] ✅ **Dual buffer system** + - PREP_BUFFER_MINUTES: 30 (time before dancing) + - REST_BUFFER_MINUTES: 60 (time after dancing) + - No buffer for recording-only participants + +### Constants +- [x] ✅ **ACCOUNT_TIER** - BASIC, SUPPORTER, COMFORT +- [x] ✅ **FAIRNESS_SUPPORTER_PENALTY** = 10 +- [x] ✅ **FAIRNESS_COMFORT_PENALTY** = 50 +- [x] ✅ **MAX_RECORDINGS_PER_PERSON** = 3 +- [x] ✅ **PREP_BUFFER_MINUTES** = 30 +- [x] ✅ **REST_BUFFER_MINUTES** = 60 + +### Impact +- Fair distribution of recording work across all participants +- Premium tiers incentivize support while reducing recording burden +- Event organizers can grant temporary tier upgrades via accountTierOverride + +--- + +## ✅ Mobile-first Design Improvements (COMPLETED 2025-11-29) + +**Status:** Completed +**Commits:** 1 commit + +### Overview +Enhanced mobile user experience with page titles, clickable usernames, and country flags. + +### Frontend Implementation +- [x] ✅ **Page titles on mobile** - Show context when no desktop sidebar +- [x] ✅ **Clickable usernames** - @username links to public profiles +- [x] ✅ **Country flags** - Display user country flags in event chat +- [x] ✅ **Responsive layout** - Optimized for small screens + +### Git Commits +1. `feat(frontend): add page titles on mobile, clickable usernames, country flags` + +--- + +## ✅ Test Bot for Automated Testing (COMPLETED 2025-11-29) + +**Status:** Completed +**Commits:** 1 commit + +### Overview +Created test bot for simulating user interactions in automated tests. + +### Implementation +- [x] ✅ **Test bot** in `backend/src/__tests__/helpers/testBot.js` +- [x] ✅ Automated user creation and cleanup +- [x] ✅ Event participation simulation +- [x] ✅ Heat declaration helpers + +### Git Commits +1. `test: add test bot for automated testing` + +--- + +## ✅ Ratings & Stats System (COMPLETED 2025-11-30) + +**Status:** Completed +**Time Spent:** ~4 hours +**Commits:** 2 commits +**Tests:** 9 E2E tests passing + +### Overview +Implemented atomic stats updates for recording fairness tracking. When users rate auto matches, the system updates recordingsDone/recordingsReceived stats atomically with race condition prevention. Manual matches don't affect stats. + +### Backend Implementation +- [x] ✅ **Stats application logic** in ratings controller + - `statsApplied` flag in Rating model prevents double-counting + - Atomic check-and-set using Prisma `updateMany` with WHERE conditions + - Source filtering: only 'auto' matches update stats + - Manual matches excluded from fairness calculations +- [x] ✅ **Race condition prevention** + - Transaction-like behavior with atomic updates + - Check `statsApplied` before applying stats + - Single database query ensures no race conditions +- [x] ✅ **Idempotency** + - Double-rating prevention at database level + - Unique constraint: (match_id, rater_id, rated_id) + - Stats update exactly once per match completion + +### Test Coverage +- [x] ✅ **E2E test suite** `backend/src/__tests__/ratings-stats-flow.test.js` (9 tests) + - TC1: Double-rating completion flow + - TC2: recordingsDone increments for recorder + - TC3: recordingsReceived increments for dancer + - TC4: Stats idempotency (no double-counting) + - TC5: statsApplied flag set after update + - TC6: Manual matches don't update stats + - TC7: Auto matches do update stats + - TC8: Race condition simulation + - TC9: Complete E2E flow verification + +### Impact +- Fair karma tracking ensures balanced recording assignments +- Race-proof implementation handles concurrent ratings +- Source filtering prevents manual matches from affecting fairness +- Frontend UI already existed in `RatePartnerPage.jsx` + +### Git Commits +1. `feat(ratings): add atomic stats updates with race condition prevention` +2. `test(ratings): add comprehensive E2E test for ratings & stats flow` + +--- + +## ✅ Matching Runs Audit & origin_run_id Tracking (COMPLETED 2025-11-30) + +**Status:** Completed +**Time Spent:** ~6 hours +**Commits:** 3 commits +**Tests:** 6 comprehensive tests + 19 matching algorithm tests + 5 incremental matching tests + +### Overview +Implemented complete audit trail for matching runs with origin_run_id tracking. Every suggestion now tracks which matching run created it, enabling per-run statistics, filtering, and audit capabilities. + +### Backend Implementation +- [x] ✅ **MatchingRun model** - Audit trail table + - `id`, `eventId`, `trigger` (manual/scheduler), `status` (running/success/failed) + - `startedAt`, `endedAt`, `matchedCount`, `notFoundCount`, `errorMessage` +- [x] ✅ **origin_run_id tracking** in RecordingSuggestion + - Every suggestion tagged with its creating run + - Preserved across incremental matching for accepted/completed suggestions + - PENDING suggestions replaced with new run ID +- [x] ✅ **Manual matching endpoint fix** `POST /api/events/:slug/run-matching` + - Now creates MatchingRun records (was missing) + - Proper error handling with failed status + - Returns runId in response +- [x] ✅ **Admin endpoints** `backend/src/routes/admin.js` + - `GET /api/admin/events/:slug/matching-runs` - List all runs for event + - `GET /api/admin/events/:slug/matching-runs/:runId/suggestions` - Get suggestions per run + - Filter parameters: `onlyAssigned`, `includeNotFound` +- [x] ✅ **Incremental matching behavior** + - PENDING suggestions: Deleted and replaced with new run ID + - ACCEPTED suggestions: Preserved, keep original origin_run_id + - COMPLETED suggestions: Preserved, keep original origin_run_id +- [x] ✅ **Scheduler integration** + - Trigger type: 'scheduler' vs 'manual' + - Automated matching creates audit records + +### Test Coverage +- [x] ✅ **Matching runs audit** `backend/src/__tests__/matching-runs-audit.test.js` (6 tests) + - TC1: origin_run_id assigned correctly + - TC2: Sequential runs create separate IDs + - TC3: Accepted suggestions preserve origin_run_id + - TC4: Filter parameters work (onlyAssigned, includeNotFound) + - TC5: Manual vs scheduler trigger differentiation + - TC6: Failed runs recorded in audit trail +- [x] ✅ **Matching algorithm** `backend/src/__tests__/matching-algorithm.test.js` (19 tests) + - Phase 1: Fundamentals (TC1-3) + - Phase 2: Collision Detection (TC4-9) + - Phase 3: Limits & Workload (TC10-11) + - Phase 4: Fairness & Tiers (TC12-16) + - Phase 5: Edge Cases (TC17-19) +- [x] ✅ **Incremental matching** `backend/src/__tests__/matching-incremental.test.js` (5 tests) +- [x] ✅ **Recording stats integration** `backend/src/__tests__/recording-stats-integration.test.js` (6 tests) + +### Documentation +- [x] ✅ **Comprehensive test guide** `docs/TESTING_MATCHING_RATINGS.md` + - Overview of all 45 matching/ratings tests + - Test scenarios and expected outcomes + - Edge cases covered + - Running instructions + +### Impact +- Complete audit trail for matching operations +- Per-run statistics and filtering +- Debugging capability: trace which run created specific suggestions +- Admin visibility into matching system performance +- Foundation for future analytics and reporting + +### Git Commits +1. `feat(matching): implement origin_run_id tracking and audit tests` +2. `fix(tests): correct socket test to use nested user.username field` +3. `test(matching): add comprehensive integration tests for matching algorithm` + +--- + +## ✅ Documentation Reorganization (COMPLETED 2025-11-30) + +**Status:** Completed +**Commits:** 2 commits + +### Overview +Streamlined documentation structure, removed duplicates, archived outdated files. + +### Changes +- [x] ✅ **README.md** - Streamlined from 645 to 365 lines (-43%) + - Removed duplication with other docs + - Focus on quick start, features, commands + - Links to detailed documentation +- [x] ✅ **SESSION_CONTEXT.md** - Updated with current status + - 342/342 tests (100% passing) + - Recent work: matching runs audit, ratings & stats + - Ready for context restoration +- [x] ✅ **Archived outdated docs** + - `CONTEXT.md` → `archive/` (duplicated in README) + - `QUICKSTART.md` → `archive/` (mentions mock auth, outdated) + - `QUICK_TEST.md` → `archive/` (outdated) +- [x] ✅ **TESTING_MATCHING_RATINGS.md** - New comprehensive test guide + - 45 tests across 5 suites + - Detailed test scenarios + - Edge cases and running instructions + +### Active Documentation +- `README.md` - Main project overview (365 lines) +- `docs/SESSION_CONTEXT.md` - Quick context restoration (224 lines) +- `docs/TODO.md` - Active tasks & roadmap +- `docs/ARCHITECTURE.md` - Technical details +- `docs/DEPLOYMENT.md` - Deployment guide +- `docs/MONITORING.md` - Operations guide +- `docs/TESTING_MATCHING_RATINGS.md` - Test documentation +- `docs/WEBRTC_TESTING_GUIDE.md` - WebRTC testing + +### Git Commits +1. `docs: update documentation with matching runs audit and complete test coverage` +2. `docs: streamline README and update SESSION_CONTEXT, archive outdated docs` + +--- + +**Last Updated:** 2025-11-30 (Matching runs audit, ratings & stats system, documentation reorganization completed) **Note:** This file is an archive of completed phases. For current status, see SESSION_CONTEXT.md or TODO.md **MVP Status:** ✅ 100% Complete - All core features implemented, tested, and production-ready -**Test Status:** 286/286 backend tests passing (73% coverage) +**Test Status:** 342/342 backend tests passing (100% ✅, 72.5% coverage)